© Xicoputini | Dreamstime

Author(s):
Gregory F. Nemet,Matthew J. Gidden,Jenna Greene,Cameron Roberts,William F. Lamb,Jan C. Minx,Stephen M. Smith,Oliver Geden,Keywan Riahi
Institution:
University of Wisconsin - Madison, IIASA, MCC, Oxford University, German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP)
Date:
March 2024
Regional Resolution:
Global
Technology Adoption
DAC
DACCS
Key Insights
  • Novel CDR methods must grow quickly in the next decade to reach the scale necessary for meeting temperature targets
  • The scale and speed required for novel CDR to reach climate relevant scale is in line with the fastest historical analogues

To meet the temperature targets agreed upon in the Paris Agreement will require both rapidly reducing emissions and scaling up carbon dioxide removal. Virtually all scenarios that limit warming to 1.5 degrees or 2 degrees C require novel CDR (for example, direct air capture with carbon capture and storage or bioenergy with carbon capture and storage). In this study, we compare the amount of novel CDR included in scenarios that reach temperature targets with other energy/climate technologies in their formative phase.

The study finds that novel CDR methods need to scale at a faster rate than they have before. The study focuses specifically on the formative phase of technology growth – between first commercialization and rapid scale-up. The speed and scale achieved in the formative phase is important to understand the feasibility of reaching levels of CDR that are relevant for meeting temperature goals.

Figure 1. Comparing formative phase of climate and energy technologies with novel CDR levels. Left panel: solid lines show the standardized formative phase and number of plants of climate and energy technologies and points show novel CDR company announcements. Right panel: solid line show the amount of carbon dioxide removal in scenarios that limit warming to 1.5 and 2 degrees C, dashed lines show the scale-up of climate and energy technologies in their formative phase.

We find that the scale up rates needed for novel carbon removal to meet these targets are within the range of historical experience for climate and energy technologies – but need to grow as fast as the fastest technologies to be climate relevant.

References

Near-term deployment of novel carbon removal to facilitate longer-term deployment
Nemet, G.F., Gidden, M.J., Greene, J., Roberts, C., Lamb, W.F., Minx, J.C., Smith, S.M., Geden, O., Riahi, K (2023)
Joule

This project has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the European Research Council (ERC) Grant Agreement No. 951542-GENIE-ERC-2020-SyG, “GeoEngineering and NegatIve Emissions pathways in Europe” (GENIE). Also, the project was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Aarhus University 2021-13

International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA)
Schlossplatz 1 – A-2361 Laxenburg, Austria
(+43 2236) 807 0 – [email protected]